Kim Davis stands ground, but same-sex couple get marriage license

Posted at 1:53 PM, Sep 14, 2015
and last updated 2015-09-14 13:53:17-04

(CNN) — America’s highest-profile county clerk, Kim Davis, returned to work Monday vowing to deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples.

But that didn’t stop Carmen and Shannon Wampler-Collins from successfully walking out of the Rowan County, Kentucky, clerk’s office with a marriage license in hand.

Monday was Davis’ first day back in her office after spending five days in jail for defying a court order and refusing to give licenses to same-sex couples.

Before starting her workday, Davis appeared defiant, saying she will not issue any marriage licenses that go against her religious beliefs — but she left the door open for her deputies to continue giving out marriage licenses to same-sex couples as long as those documents do not have Davis’ name or title on them.

The marriage license that the couple received said “pursuant to federal court order” on it, and instead of listing Davis’ name and Rowan County, it says city of Morehead, the county seat.

Davis’ work-around — not to sign licenses but not to interfere with her deputies if they do so — produced more questions than answers.

She acknowledged she is not sure on the legality of licenses altered in such a way.

On her first day back at work, Davis read a statement calling for state authorities to find a solution to accommodate her religious beliefs.

“Effective immediately, and until an accommodation is provided by those with the authority to provide it, any marriage license issued by my office will not be issued or authorized by me,” Davis said.

In the meantime, she has offered what she considers an interim solution, but it is unclear if it passes legal muster:

U.S. District Judge David Bunning “indicated last week that he was willing to accept altered marriage license even though he was not certain of their validity,” Davis said. “I, too, have great doubts whether the license issued under these conditions are even valid.”

Parsing Davis’ statement

Davis was clear on one thing: She will not sign any marriage licenses for same-sex couples, and her deputies are not authorized to issue them either.

But, she added, if her deputies go against her orders and provide marriage certificates to same-sex couples anyway, she will not take any action against them.

So, is Davis continuing to defy the order from the judge? Even experts said they weren’t sure at first glance.

CNN senior legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin said that Kentucky law might allow for a deputy’s signature to be valid on a marriage license, even without the clerk’s consent. But if the documents are altered to remove Davis’ name and title, a court may have to rule on their validity.

Governor: No special session

Since being released from jail last week, Davis has been lying low and opening boxes of letters sent to her while she was in jail.

“I am deeply moved by all those who prayed for me,” she said in a statement. “All I can say is that I am amazed and very grateful.”

Davis’ legal team has been busy on her behalf, filing motions that suggest her brief stint in jail did nothing to change her mind.

On Friday, for example, her defense attorneys asked Bunning for injunctive relief, which essentially amounts to a request that she be exempt from having to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples until the matter is resolved by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The judge denied the motion.

Davis’ attorney, Mat Staver, said a solution would be to remove not just Davis’ name and office from the marriage licenses themselves but from the process entirely. Have the state issue them instead, he said.

Sounds simple enough, but under current Kentucky state law, the authority to issue marriage licenses rests solely with each of the state’s 120 county clerks, meaning it would take an act of the Legislature to transfer that authority. The Legislature, however, doesn’t convene until January 5, and Gov. Steve Beshear has said he has no intention of calling lawmakers back to Frankfort for an emergency session before then.

Legislation in the works

Kentucky state Senate President Robert Stivers told CNN last week that a legislative solution was in the works and it would likely pass quickly when lawmakers convene in January.

But that is still some three months away.

“It’s a very, very difficult decision that no one wants to have,” said Staver, Davis’ attorney. “Choose your job, or choose your faith.”


Judge orders Kim Davis released, bars her from withholding marriage licenses

Kentucky clerk ordered to jail for failing to issue same-sex marriage licenses

Kim Davis is jailed; clerk’s office to issue marriage licenses to gay couples

SCOTUS: Kentucky clerk must issue same-sex marriage licenses

Kentucky clerk who won’t issue marriage licenses to gay couples has been divorced three times