Court delays Obamacare contraception mandate for 2 nonprofits

Posted at 11:39 AM, Jan 01, 2014

(CNN) — The U.S. Supreme Court has temporarily exempted two Catholic Church-affiliated nonprofits from requirements to provide contraceptive coverage to its employees under the Affordable Care Act.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor issued a brief order late Tuesday, hours before the controversial Obama administration mandates were set to go into effect.

The Little Sisters of the Poor — a charity congregation of Roman Catholic women in Denver — and the Illinois-based Christian Brothers Services had filed a lawsuit objecting to the contraception mandate, saying it violated their religious and moral beliefs. Some religious-affiliated groups were required to comply with contraception coverage or face hefty fines.

Sotomayor said the two groups were exempted from the mandates until at least Friday, when the federal government faces a deadline to file a legal response in the case. Another high court order is expected later this week.

While the Supreme Court action was just directed at the two Catholic-affiliated organizations, it may have the practical effect of temporarily delaying implementation of the contraception mandates for nearly all the dozens of religious groups that filed separate appeals around the country in recent months.

“We defer to the Department of Justice on litigation matters,” a White House official on Wednesday said in reacting to the high court order.

But the official said that the Obama administration remains “confident that our final rules strike the balance of providing women with free contraceptive coverage while preventing non-profit religious organizations with religious objections to contraceptive coverage from having to contract, arrange, pay, or refer for such coverage.”

Three other similar emergency appeals from Catholic archdioceses in Michigan, Tennessee and Washington, D.C., were filed with the high court Tuesday, but they were not acted upon because lower federal appeals courts had already issued injunctions temporarily blocking enforcement.

These organizations are all asking for at least a delay of the Obamacare requirement that employers offer contraception and “abortion-inducing drug” coverage as part of their health care offerings to workers.

The issue has been a major sticking point with religious groups and private for-profit companies that have strong moral objections.

Under final rules negotiated between the administration and various outside groups in June, churches and houses of worships themselves are exempt from the mandate.

But other nonprofit religious-affiliated groups such as church-run hospitals, parochial schools and charities like the Little Sisters of the Poor, must either provide no-cost contraception coverage or have a third-party insurer provide separate benefits without the employer’s direct involvement.

“Tomorrow, applicants (the Catholic organizations) will be forced to choose between onerous penalties or becoming complicit in a grave moral wrong,” according to the court filing from the groups.

“Just as an individual may be held accountable for aiding and abetting a crime he did not personally commit, so too may a Catholic violate the moral law in certain circumstances by cooperating in the commission by others of acts contrary to Catholic beliefs.

“For some, religion provides an essential source of guidance both about what constitutes wrongful conduct and the degree to which those who assist others in committing wrongful conduct themselves bear moral culpability,” the groups said.

The appeal came after the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, Archbishop Joseph Kurtz of Louisville, pressed Obama on the issue.

He asked Obama in a letter that went further than the appeal to Roberts and Kagan to exempt some businesses and religious-affiliated institutions from enforcement of the mandate — through fines — until the Supreme Court rules on the matter.

He pointed to other delays the administration has made in the law, such as putting off until 2015 the requirement for all employers with more than 50 workers to provide health coverage.

But Kurtz notes that “an employer who chooses, out of charity and good will, to provide” health insurance for employees can still face fines if that employer does not want to comply with the contraception requirement.

“In effect, the government seems to be telling employees that they are better off with no employer health plan at all than with a plan that does not cover contraceptives,” he writes.

The letter represents a major first act by Kurtz, who was elected president of the bishops’ conference in November, succeeding Archbishop of New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan.

The Supreme Court agreed last month to hear two cases involving for-profit corporations that contend their religious liberty is violated by the law.

Among the plaintiffs is Hobby Lobby, Inc., a nationwide chain of about 500 arts and crafts stores.

At issue is whether private companies can refuse with the mandates under the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act , which requires government to seek “least burdensome” and narrowly tailored means for any law that interferes with religious convictions.

The privately held company does not object to funding all forms of contraception – such as condoms and diaphragms – for their roughly 13,000 employees, which Hobby Lobby says represent a variety of faiths.

But the Green family, which owns Hobby Lobby, said in court filings it objects to contraceptives like the morning after pill, which it says constitutes abortion and violates its faith.

Hobby Lobby calculated that its refusal to provide the coverage could result in a fine of up to $1.3 million daily.

The White House said in November that it believes a requirement on contraceptives is “lawful and essential to women’s health.”