Men’s memories worse than women’s – especially with age, study finds

Posted at 6:57 AM, Mar 18, 2015
and last updated 2015-03-18 06:57:03-04

(CNN) — Ladies, science has proven what you’ve been saying all along: A man’s memory is worse than yours. Not only that, but their brains are smaller, at least the part that controls memories.

“That’s right, that’s what the data says,” said Dr. Clifford Jack of the Mayo Clinic. “We see worse memory and worse brain volumes in men than women from [age] 40s onward.”

In a study of 1,246 cognitively normal people between the ages of 30 and 95, Jack and fellow researchers found that while memory started to decline for both sexes at age 30, male memory was worse than women overall, especially after age 40.

And in males, the hippocampus, the part of the brain that controls memory, was also smaller than women’s, especially after age 60.

“The men’s hippocampus starts off a little bit above average in the young people in the study,” said neurologist Dr. Charles DeCarli, who reviewed the study before it was published in JAMA Neurology. “But then it falls way below average in the older men as compared to the older women.”

“It’s no surprise, as your brain shrinks, memory declines,” added Jack.

But wait, overall men’s brains are bigger than women’s, right?

“It’s true, women’s brains are smaller than men’s brains, but brain size scales with your height,” Jack said. “And so if you correct for head size, which we did, women’s hippocampus and verbal memory is better than men’s.”

The female advantage

One of the major reasons females trump males in this head game: the protective effects of hormones. Estrogen has been shown to shield pre-menopausal women from hypertension, bone loss, heart disease, even urinary tract infections.

“Men can’t do anything about the absence of the protective effect of estrogen,” Jack said. “And while it goes away for some women by 50, if a woman has had a lifetime of protective advantage, there’s still quite a residual effect for a number of years past that.”

“It’s not just estrogen, there’s progesterone, luteinizing hormone, blood volume, let me tell you, women are different from men,” DeCarli said. “Men may never achieve the same level of memory performance because their brains are developing differently from the beginning.”

“You can even think about that anthropologically,” DeCarli said. “Women may have developed skills and strategies over our evolutionary development to keep track of stuff that helps their memory that men just never acquired.”

Another advantage women have over men: less risk for vascular disease.

“Hypertension, diabetes, smoking: Historically, men have had much higher risk factors than women,” Jack said. “The same things that harm your vessels harm your brain.”

Unusual finding

A surprising finding of the study is that the decline in memory for both men and women had nothing to do with a connection to brain disorders, such as Alzheimer’s.

“One of the big conclusions that had been drawn in the past was that the memory and brain-volume declines you see in middle age are probably due to underlying Alzheimer’s pathology,” said Jack. “What we found that was quite different is that these declines that begin in the 30s and continue through old age occur well before we see evidence of Alzheimer’s disease.”

The authors said they believe this is good news.

“If you can’t remember lists, if you can’t remember someone’s name, when you’re age 50 or 60, don’t be alarmed,” Jack said. “Because the odds are that it’s not evidence of early Alzheimer’s disease.”

The bad news? The study says your brain is going to age. Period.

“No matter how you slice and dice these measures of neurodegeneration, everything declines with age, very few people remain normal into the late 80s,” Jack said. “It starts first with men, but women follow.”

What can we do to keep that aging process at bay as long as possible? Being genetically lucky helps, of course. But experts agree: Anyone can benefit from a healthy lifestyle, and especially exercise of both the body and brain.

“You want to keep learning,” DeCarli said. “Learn a new language, develop a new skill like playing piano or guitar, drawing, painting. There’s definitely good evidence learning things stimulates brain hormones that help develop our brains.”

“The big thing for your brain is aerobic exercise,” Jack said. “The more the better. You don’t have to run a marathon every week. The biggest benefits come from doing a half an hour of interval bursts. That’s the thing that really seems to optimize your aerobic fitness and helps your brain.”