Guy claims victory, Stolle says recount ‘highly likely’ in Virginia Beach race

Posted at 7:00 PM, Nov 08, 2019

VIRGINIA BEACH, Va. – While election season is over for most candidates across the state, two competitors in the Hampton Roads area could be headed into overtime.

Before provisional ballots were counted, Democrat Nancy Guy led Del. Chris Stolle, R-Virginia Beach, by 18 votes in the race for House District 83, which covers portions of Norfolk and Virginia Beach.

Virginia House Democrats issued a statement Friday evening declaring Guy the winner of the close race “after a long and precise ballot counting process,” and said Guy currently holds a 26-vote margin over Stolle with four ballots outstanding.

The first major step in the certification process is counting provisional ballots. Provisional ballots are cast by voters who do not bring proper identification to their polling place on Election Day. Instead, they fill out a provisional ballot and have until noon on the Friday after the election to submit a copy of their identification to have their ballot counted.

Christine Lewis, a deputy registrar in Virginia Beach, said 218 provisional ballots were cast in the city. The Department of Elections website lists the estimated count of provisional ballots between Norfolk and Virginia Beach as 294, though 70 of those were from people not registered to vote. Virginia Beach is divided into eight House districts: 21, 77, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85 and 90.

Stephanie Iles, Norfolk’s voter registrar said that four provisional ballots cast at the East Ocean View precinct were for the 83rd district. That precinct, which Guy won by 99 votes, is the only Norfolk precinct represented by the 83rd District.

The deadline to provide identification expired at noon Friday. Iles said that Norfolk’s provisional ballot canvass and the certification of the election results will be completed on Tuesday.

After the election is certified, the Virginia Department of Elections allows the losing candidate 10 days to petition for a recount if the difference between the votes is within 1%. The current margin between Guy and Stolle is .08% — though the website hadn’t been updated at the time of publishing to reflect the new 26 votes claimed by Guy.

Stolle has served in the House since 2010. He faced tougher odds in the district after the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a lower court’s decision that the previous House of Delegates map was racially gerrymandered. According to the Virginia Public Access Project, the newly drawn district is 12.4 percentage points more favorable to Democrats than before.

“I believe that every vote needs to be counted,” Stolle said. “We are anxiously awaiting the results of the provisional ballots. This election is so close that it is highly likely that it will go to a recount.”

When reached for comment late Friday, Stolle’s campaign said they stand by their earlier statement and had nothing more to add.

Guy, a former member of the Virginia Beach School Board, also claimed victory Tuesday night moments before the Associated Press called the race in Stolle’s favor.

When reached by phone Friday afternoon, Guy’s campaign manager Sandra Brandt said that the campaign won’t have news until after the provisional ballots are counted.

“We got an update that Virginia Beach is about halfway through counting provisional ballots as of 3 p.m.,” Brandt said. “It’s looking like it will be an all day affair.”

Norfolk has until Tuesday to complete the provisional canvass and certification of election results, according to Iles.

With a potential recount ahead, the race could remain in doubt for several weeks.

The losing candidate could petition the Richmond Circuit Court, who would then set the procedures for the recount. The cities would pay for a recount if the margin between the two candidates is half of a percent or less, or if the candidate who requests the recount is declared the winner afterward. Otherwise, the candidate who requested the recount must pay the associated costs, according to the Department of Elections.

The Hampton Roads region is no stranger to recounts in General Assembly races. A 2017 recount in House District 94 received widespread coverage after Del. David Yancey, R-Newport News, and Democratic challenger Shelly Simondstied after a recount. Yancey was declared the winner in a random drawing from a ceramic bowl that served as the tiebreaker. Simonds beat Yancey handily — by almost 3,500 votes — in an election re-match on Tuesday.

On Friday, Del. Roxann Robinson, R-Chesterfield, was ahead of her Democratic challenger Larry Barnett by 194 votes. Barnett issued a statement Friday night that he will not request a recount.

Del. Nick Freitas, R-Culpeper, seems set to clinch a victorious write-in campaign for House District 30. The total of submitted write-in ballots was over 4,100 ballots higher than challenger Ann Ridgeway.

Democrats will maintain control of the House of Delegates whether or not Guy wins a recount. If Guy and Freitas keep their leads, Democrats hold 55 seats to the 45 held by Republicans.

By Jason Boleman
Capital News Service

Click here for our full coverage on the 2019 Virginia General Assembly election.